Which E-Commerce Platform is Better to use (Shopify vs Amazon)

Which E-Commerce Platform is Better to use (Shopify vs Amazon)

In the rapidly evolving world of e-commerce, choosing the right platform is crucial for the success of your online business. Shopify and Amazon are two of the most popular platforms available, each offering distinct features that cater to different business needs. Understanding the key differences between Shopify and Amazon can help you make an informed decision on which platform is the best fit for your business.

1. Business Model: Independence vs. Marketplace

Shopify: Shopify is a dedicated e-commerce platform that allows you to create your online store. It gives you complete control over your brand, customer experience, and business operations. As a Shopify merchant, you can design your store, choose your domain, and manage your marketing and sales strategies. Shopify is ideal for businesses that want to build a unique brand identity and have direct customer relationships.

Amazon: Amazon is a vast online marketplace where you can list your products alongside millions of other sellers. When selling on Amazon, you leverage its enormous customer base and infrastructure but have less control over your brand and customer interactions. Amazon’s marketplace model is ideal for businesses looking to tap into an existing, high-traffic platform with extensive reach.

2. Customer Base: Brand Loyalty vs. Marketplace Traffic

Shopify: Shopify helps you build and maintain customer loyalty by allowing you to create personalized experiences. Since you own the customer data, you can use it to tailor marketing campaigns, improve customer service, and build long-term relationships. Shopify’s model fosters brand loyalty and repeat business.

Amazon: Amazon’s marketplace attracts millions of customers daily, providing instant access to a vast audience. However, these customers are primarily loyal to Amazon, not the individual sellers. While Amazon’s traffic can boost sales, it can be challenging to differentiate your brand and establish customer loyalty within the marketplace.

3. Fees and Costs: Subscription vs. Commission

Shopify: Shopify operates on a subscription-based model, with different pricing tiers depending on the features and tools you need. You pay a monthly fee, plus transaction fees if you use external payment gateways. The predictable costs make budgeting easier, and you keep the majority of your sales revenue.

Amazon: Amazon charges sellers a variety of fees, including referral fees (a percentage of each sale), closing fees, and monthly subscription fees for those on the Professional selling plan. These fees can add up, especially for high-volume sellers, and often reduce profit margins.

4. Marketing and SEO: DIY vs. Built-in Audience

Shopify: With Shopify, you’re responsible for driving traffic to your store through marketing and SEO efforts. While this requires more work, it also means you have control over your marketing strategy and can optimize for organic search results. Shopify integrates with various marketing tools, making it easier to manage campaigns across multiple channels.

Amazon: Amazon provides a built-in audience, so you don’t need to invest heavily in marketing to attract customers. However, competition is fierce, and your products can easily get lost among similar offerings. Amazon’s internal search algorithm heavily influences visibility, so sellers often need to invest in Amazon Ads to stand out.

5. Branding and Customization: Full Control vs. Limited

Shopify: Shopify offers extensive customization options, allowing you to design your store’s look and feel to match your brand identity. You can choose from hundreds of themes, customize the user interface, and add apps to enhance functionality. This flexibility is ideal for businesses that prioritize brand consistency.

Amazon: Branding opportunities on Amazon are limited. While you can create a storefront on Amazon, the overall layout and design options are constrained. Your product listings must follow Amazon’s standardized format, making it difficult to differentiate your brand visually from competitors.

6. Logistics and Fulfillment: In-House vs. Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA)

Shopify: Shopify gives you the freedom to manage your inventory, shipping, and fulfillment processes or integrate with third-party logistics providers. This allows for more control over order fulfillment and customer experience. Shopify also offers its fulfillment network for those who want to outsource logistics.

Amazon: Amazon’s Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) service is a significant advantage for sellers. With FBA, Amazon handles storage, packing, shipping, and customer service, making it easier to scale your business. However, using FBA means adhering to Amazon’s strict rules and potentially higher fees.

Shopify 

Amazon

Platform - Type

Website builder and host

Third-party marketplace

Pricing

Introductory offer starts at INR 20 per month for three months, then as low as INR 1,499 per month (billed annually)

INR 82.41 (99 cents) per each item sold on individual plan; INR 3,328.99 ($39.99) per month for professional plan

Templates and Design

Equipped with an online web builder and a diverse collection of professional and free templates for various industry types

No control over design of amazon store

Marketing options 

Social media integration, gift cards, discount codes, Google Ads credits

Amazon paid Ads, competitive pricing 

Transaction Fee

Zero percent on all plans only if uing shopify payments. If using an existing payment gateway, transaction fees are 2% for shopify lite and basic shopify; 1% for shopify and 0.5 % for advanced shopify

All sellers must pay a referral fee based on product category

Mobile-Friendly

Yes

Yes

Customer Support

Shopify lite offers 24/7 live chat and email; all other plans offer 24/7 live chat, email and phone support 

Contact amazon seller support team via seller central account

 

Conclusion : 

 

Choosing between Shopify and Amazon depends on your business goals and priorities. If you’re looking to build a brand, have control over your store, and create a unique customer experience, Shopify is the way to go. On the other hand, if you want immediate access to a large customer base with minimal effort in marketing and logistics, Amazon’s marketplace could be a better fit. Understanding these key differences will help you make an informed decision and set your business on the path to success.

Curious about how we can transform your online presence? Discover the possibilities!

Learn More

Back to blog